Role of Women in Indian Society
Greetings from Cape Town. Our days in Cape Town continue to be not very noteworthy, so this post is about the role of women in Indian society. Everything in Indian society seemed complex, and few things seemed generalizable across the entire country. That said, the role of women was particularly difficult for me to understand. Women seem to be treated unfairly by a large segment of society, and in many cases, just badly. For example:
- the dowry system (which makes girl children a big financial burden)
- lingering societal enthusiasm for the now obsolete practice of sati, when the living widow throws herself onto the cremation pyre of her husband
- widely acknowledged gender-selected abortion and female infanticide
- societal exclusion of widows (eg, from religious festivals)
- “honor killings” of women who have been raped or had out-of-wedlock sex (relatively uncommon)
- female adult literacy of ~40%, vs, male adult literacy of nearly 60%
- expectations of very conservative dress, including head covering and veils in many cases, for both Hindu and Muslim women
At the same time, women are also idealized and exalted:
- The “five mothers” (birth mother, cow mother, Mother Ganga, mother Earth, and Mother Om) at the center of Hinduism
- Proliferation of powerful female Hindu goddesses (eg, Kali, the ferocious destroyer)
- Success of many female politicians across multiple parties
- Societal obsession with Bollywood actresses
To highlight the paradoxes, and as a testament to my confusion, I tried to summarize all of the women-related stories in the Times of India on November 20th. The few Indians who I have discussed this topic with say that “these newspaper stories aren’t representative” for a variety of reasons. I invite you to read the summaries and to draw your own conclusions:
Story 1 - an update on the “sex ratio” in Gurgaon, a wealthy suburb of Delhi. ”Sex ratio” means the number of girl births registered per thousand boy births. The natural rate is about 950, so Gurgaon’s rate of 847 implies that about 11-12% of all girl-fetus pregnancies are terminated (and/or infant girls are killed). Sex ratio is such a commonly used term that it was not defined in the story. This is an ongoing and closely tracked issue across India. It will be interesting to see what societal changes come about from the demographic inevitability of having ~100 million young adult men in a giant, unmarryable bachelor herd in about 20 years. If markets work, dowry prices should go down. Let’s hope that the outcome is not much worse.
Story 2 - a Delhi pedestrian saw a stray dog dragging a plastic bag around, and discovered a living five-day-old girl child in the bag. Police described this as “a pretty common thing.” The infant survived.
Story 3 - undercover women police officers have been deployed at the Indian International Trade Fair to reduce the incidence of “Eve teasing,” which is an aggressive form of public harassment. The commander of the unit said that the officers get the offenders to “apologize, or we bash him in front of his friends.” Police say that women from the Northeast parts of India are seen as “easy targets” for Eve teasing, because they are “too soft spoken to retort”
Story 4 - about upcoming local elections, where two of the three party leaders (Gandhi from Congress, Mayawati from BSP) are women
Story 5 - a regular feature called “Woman on Top,” which details triumphs of women. This column was about a woman in the U.S. who won a sexual harassment lawsuit.
Story 6 - a long feature story on the difficulties that expat wives have in getting legal permission to work in India. The story suggested that it was so difficult that they should give up, enjoy being in India, and raise their children.
Story 7 - short profiles of women political candidates in Kashmir, summarized in a table of characteristics of Kashmiri women (From: uneducated, politically unaware, unemployed, and possessing low self esteem, To: educated, politically aware, employed, confident)
Story 8 - entitled “My Wife, My Trophy,” which argues, in earnest, for “a truth, universally acknowledged, that a rich man needs a beautiful, young wife”
Story 9 - a weird science story, citing a study that demonstrated that the use of hairspray by pregnant women increases the risk significantly of “genital defects” in boy children.
Story 10 - entitled “Macho Girls,” which claims that Indian women are “assertive and hard as nails” and have “Learned to talk tough and walk rough.” This story had a lot of hot photos of beautiful young women.
Story 11 - entitled “Sexy Is In the Mind,” with a racy picture of Eva Longoria, and the recommendation that overweight women should “tell themselves they are slim.”
Obviously, it is difficult to draw any conclusions from some personal observations and a bunch of newspaper stories. India’s long-term success, however, seems closely connected to greatly normalizing the role of women, or at least not treating them so generally badly.
Thinking about this topic made me for sure appreciate my strong mother and sister, and my strong wife. It also made me appreciate more the accomplishments of prominent and successful Indian women.


























